The point is unclear:
1) Tickets to be provided to life members was a policy that was used. And if this is the cause of the lack of funds, then
the wisdom of that policy could be questioned. The method you describe was used to make Eden one of the foremost stadia in
the world, and perhaps the same policy means a lull for a while. So, if someone ought be blamed for this mess (and it is not necessary ... Eden has enjoyed a prominence for long, and this policy could create a passionate fan base ... all good things), it is the policy makers of that time.
The policy has made Eden the most passionate stadium for cricket in the country. There is nothing like a packed Eden, it is something else. So there is no question of blame. Yes the floodlight thing is embarrassing, and the CAB said they will make their own generators and not depend on CESC anymore - the matter should end there. There will always be a lack of funds to a state board (see it in the backdrop of the 25 crore renovation project). The main source of funds for Indian cricket is through TV rights, and the key to that is held by the BCCI.
Look at the BCCI's policy wrt to Wankhede. They are paying 50 crore to MCA for WC renovation (despite Wankhede being half the size of Eden) and on top of that they paid another 23 crore for a vague "cricket development". Why the differential treatment? The "Western Union" moniker is not without reason!
2) From the figures posted by Cernunnos, it is totally unclear that this is the reason. For he seems to suggest that Eden still sells more tickets (as percentage) than the rest. So, it does not make sense that the life member -free ticket stuff is the reason for all this. But CP's numbers and Cernu's numbers are vastly different
.
I didn't suggest that, the percentage is similar, but the volume is different, so that is why people in Kolkata don't feel the pinch as much.
3) I honestly don't see the point of having tests in venues where people never show up. ODI/T20s in such places are fine since people throng the grounds anyway. Similarly, in the recent past, Chennai has had tests at times when they should not (just about everyone agreed that those times were best for rains). It would make sense to rotate tests among venues where there is viewership rather than send them to far flung places. This could help stadia like Eden if there are financial problems.
It is also a matter of tradition, on which test cricket is rooted. Without that sense of occasion, the mystique is missing. A batting legend like Lara has said that he rues not having played a test at the Eden. He would never have said the same about Ahmedabad or Rohtak.
4)While sabotage may be a conspiracy theory (maybe I can suggest an even more probable conspiracy theory ... given the infighting in CAB, someone from the other camp was responsible for a sabotage?) there is no denying that there was politics going on between the BCCI and CAB. Whether that really led to clear cut victimization in terms of funds is a separate question. In order to make that allegation, one needs to supply more details.
Witholding of funds which were rightfully due to CAB not proof? The BCCI also did this in 2006 and immediately released when Dalmiya was ousted. Isn't that enough proof? What about the different funding for Wankhede?
5. I don't agree with KIC that each association should get the same amount of money either (although this statement may simply be because I am misunderstanding the situation). Yes, a larger stadium should imply larger earnings. But money spent by the board to maintain facilities should also be larger for larger stadia.
Agree with you, it is a silly notion. Especially in IPL when board hands are tied due to
max. tickets going to the franchisees. Red Chillies made 20 crore from ticket sales at the Eden (much more than anywhere else). Yet Eden got the same maintenance fee of 3.5 crore that Sawai Man Singh stadium got, with 1/3 the size of Eden. Again, these arbitrary rules were made to cut Eden to size, after having got rid of Dalmiya through false cases and installed a puppet regime.