Print

[Total Members Voted:]

Oh Yes

4 (50%)

No Bhaji is the man!

2 (25%)

Easy way out, let both play

2 (25%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Voting closed: October 31, 2009, 09:02:04 AM

Please post once and this message will disappear! Introduce yourself, say hello, jump into a discussion...

[broadbat]

One day to go.....

[keep-it-cool]

I'll give Bhajji this series. He has to be told that he will be judged on wicket taking ability rather than just containment.

With Jadeja doing reasonably well with the ball so far and Yuvi + Raina available as options, I dont see a slot for Mishra other than as Bhajji's replacement.

[broadbat]

Harbhajan not a force against Aussies

G. Viswanath

TROUBLED TIMES: Statistics show that Harbhajan Singh’s form has dipped against the Australian batsmen of late.
Mumbai: Let’s face the fact: Harbhajan Singh’s form has been dipping against the Australian willow wielders. They have countered him efficiently and dominated the Indian on many occasions.

Harbhajan has only 10 wickets to show in the last 16 matches spread over a period of three years. Nothing has gone his way in the opening two matches of the ongoing series at Vadodara and Nagpur either.

Harbhajan’s meagre collection of wickets should have nudged the national selectors to consider Ravichandran Ashwin. The Tamil Nadu off-spinner is 23, has played 20 first class matches, taken 80 wickets at 27.46, played 29 one-day matches and taken 36 wickets at 27.58. His performance in 14 Twenty20 matches is 17 wickets at 15.76.

A tyro indeed for a spinner, but having offered him a Central Contract last year, the selectors regard him as the second best off-spinner in the land.

With the series placed 1-1, the selectors did not deem it fit to make a bold move. And Ashwin doesn’t figure in the Board President’s XI for the three-day match against Sri Lanka.

After his smart batting in the first of the Hero Honda Cup seven-match one-day series, Ponting made a point. It’s not an off-the-cuff remark, but a calculated and telling one. Ponting said he was happy the way his team handled Harbhajan’s bowling and that they now have to deal with him as a batsman in the death overs.

Rough treatment
Harbhajan has received some rough treatment from the Australian batsmen and it is amply reflected in the scoresheet. If his analysis of 10-0-57-1 at Vadodara prompted Ponting to go gung-ho, the off-spinner’s figures of 10-0-62-1 at Nagpur has just about confirmed the efficacy of the Australians strategy to subdue him.

With neither Zaheer Khan nor Anil Kumble (retired) featuring in the Indian attack, the Australians were right in regarding Harbhajan as the fulcrum. Skipper Mahendra Singh Dhoni used his primary spinner for 20 overs and all overs were scored off.

Australia’s bugbear in Test rubbers (14 Tests, 79 wickets at 28.82) since the start of the new millennium in more ways than one, Harbhajan has not been the same force in 50-over games against the Australians; a stark anomaly he’s never been able to correct.

The off-spinner has managed to get 26 wickets in 30 ODIs. His form, and surprisingly in matches played in India, has never been good. In 17 matches he has 12 wickets with a strike rate of 80.50 and with an economy rate of 81.47.

Where the combination of John Buchanan and Steve Waugh may not have succeeded in mastering Harbhajan, the Australian team under Ponting has.

In the recent ICC Champions Trophy clash at the Centurion, Harbhajan was scored off almost every ball (9-0-54-0).

The Indian’s analysis against Australia in the previous seven-match home series and the Commonwealth Bank Series in early 2008 are a fair indication of the manner in which Ponting’s team has put on its gloves and nailed him.

The Australians will strive to be on top of Harbhajan’s bowling, but the Indian may look at his previous best at the Kotla — five for 31 against England in March 2006 — and return to his wicket-taking ways against Australia.

© Copyright 2000 - 2009 The Hindu

[keep-it-cool]

Whoa ..where did Ashwin suddenly come from?

[broadbat]

HS continuing to be useless in picking up wickets when even Raina gets one.

[keep-it-cool]

He's in a really poor form patch. Even Dhoni - for the first time perhaps - acknowledged this.